Thursday, December 19, 2013

Philomena: Guilt and Grace at the Movies


Philomena Lee, played by Judi Dench, had a child when she was a naïve teenager who had never had reproduction explained to her. She gave birth at the convent she’d been sent to, and her son was put up for adoption as part of the deal. Fifty years later she still thinks of him constantly and wonders if he ever thinks of her.

Enter Martin Sixsmith, a former BBC reporter who took the fall for a scandal, though he wasn’t at fault. Martin agrees to help Philomena track down her son.

Martin is a jaded, worldly guy who is condescending about the beliefs and ideas of the older woman he is helping. He is writing Philomena’s situation as a human-interest story as a way to get back into reporting. He is angry about what happened to him, and his general bitterness only becomes more inflamed by Philomena’s story.

Philomena, on the other hand, has no axe to grind, in spite of the suffering she endured at the hands of the nuns in her youth. She just wants to know her son.

These two travel together (in reality they just talked on the phone a lot, but that’s hard to turn into a movie) following up leads. Philomena struggles with her own guilt over her son, while Martin is utterly annoyed that she could be feeling guilty when he sees all of this as the fault of the Catholic church.

His atheism and her devout Catholicism make for an interesting combination as he seeks retribution while she espouses forgiveness.

I really loved this movie and it has stayed in my mind. Judi Dench is fabulous, as is to be expected, and Steve Coogan portrays Martin with a great blend of coldness and undesired compassion. The movie asks hard questions about faith and forgiveness, but it leaves room for redemption and grace.

 

No comments:

Post a Comment